The Perils of Online Contracting
With the growing trend towards online contracting, a new set of legal issues have emerged to challenge courts and lawyers. Consumers may no longer physically sign a contract; instead, they must click a button, check a box or scroll through pages of terms of service and privacy policies. These contracts have become a ubiquitous feature of life in the digital age, but they present unique challenges that have not yet been fully resolved.
The Procedural Challenges
The process of online contracting raises a number of complex challenges, primarily related to procedural justice. All too often, there is no real opportunity for negotiation or meaningful consent when a consumer clicks “I Agree” on a website. Furthermore, these contracts invariably contain mandatory arbitration clauses that eliminate the right to sue in court. Thus, consumers may be left with no meaningful remedies if they are treated unfairly by the companies with which they contract.
The Substantive Challenges
Online contracts also raise significant substantive legal issues. These contracts are typically drafted by lawyers, who use very broad and vague language to protect companies from liability. For example, a company may require a consumer to agree to refrain from suing for all “claims, controversies, losses, liabilities, damages, costs, penalties, and expenses” arising from their use of a website. From a legal perspective, this language is highly protective of the company’s interests, but it also makes it very difficult for consumers to challenge the company in court if they have been wronged.
The Technological Challenges
The process of online contracting also presents technological challenges. Consumers often agree to online terms of service agreements without fully understanding the implications of doing so, because the terms are buried deep in lengthy privacy policies or terms of service documents. This has led to the development of various technological solutions aimed at making these documents more accessible and understandable, but these solutions are still in their infancy and have not been adopted on a wide scale.
The Regulatory Challenges
The online contracting landscape is also challenging from a regulatory perspective. In many cases, it is difficult to determine which laws apply to particular contractual relationships. For example, a company may be based in one country, while its users are located in dozens of others. The laws of these different countries may conflict with one another, or there may be no applicable laws at all. This creates a legal “wild west” that is difficult for consumers to navigate.
The Future of Online Contracting
Given the challenges posed by online contracting, it is clear that the status quo is not sustainable. Regulators must take a more proactive approach to ensure that consumers are not taken advantage of by the companies with whom they contract. This may involve mandating certain procedural protections for consumers before they are allowed to enter into a contract online, or it may involve restricting the use of certain types of mandatory arbitration clauses.
Although there is no single solution to the problems posed by online contracting, it is clear that it is an area that needs more regulation and oversight. As more and more transactions move online, it is likely that these issues will become even more pressing. The legal community must work together to develop solutions that protect consumers while still allowing companies to do business in the digital age. Only then can we ensure that online contracting is fair, transparent, and equitable for all parties involved.
In conclusion, the rise of online contracting has created a host of legal challenges that must be addressed. By focusing on the procedural, substantive, technological, and regulatory aspects of online contracting, we can begin to develop solutions that work for all parties involved. The legal community must remain vigilant in monitoring developments in this area, and must be prepared to advocate for the rights of consumers in the digital age.
Read more about this topic at
Mind Over Matter: Exploring Critical Thinking Skills | Prek 12
Mind Over Matter: Exploring Critical-Thinking Skills | Prek 12